Death Row, Execution

Byron Lewis Black | Triple Murder In Nashville

Byron Lewis Black was convicted of murdering his girlfriend, Angela Clay (29), and her daughters Latoya (9) and Lakeisha (6) in Nashville on March 28, 1988.

Byron Lewis Black | Triple Murder

American Killer

Latest Update November 12, 2025

Byron Lewis Black | Triple Murder

  • Name: Bryon Lewis Black
  • Jurisdiction: Tennessee (Davidson County)
  • Crimes: First-degree murder (x3) by firearm
  • Date of offense: March 28, 1988 (Wade Ave., Nashville)
  • Arrest/Charge: 1988; tried 1989 (capital on Lakeisha)
  • Verdict/Sentence: March 8–10, 1989 – guilty on all counts; death (Lakeisha), life + life (Angela & Latoya)
  • Execution: Aug. 5, 2025, lethal injection (single-drug pentobarbital), Riverbend MSI; pronounced 10:43 a.m.
  • Controversies: ICD/pacemaker issue; TN Supreme Court allowed execution without prior deactivation; witnesses reported pain; later autopsy analysis publicized.

Classifications & Characteristics

Byron Black’s case falls squarely into intimate-partner homicide escalating to family annihilation: a domestic triple murder that included two child victims and occurred while the offender was on a weekend furlough from the Davidson County workhouse (he was serving a two-year sentence for the earlier malicious shooting of Angela’s estranged husband, Bennie). The risk profile shows classic lethality markers seen in IPV: separation/reconciliation turbulence, prior threats (“If I can’t have you, won’t nobody have you”), stalking/door-kicking behavior, easy access to a firearm, and the attack timed in the pre-dawn hours when victims were most vulnerable.

Forensic characteristics indicate a targeted, close-range shooting sequence inside a locked apartment with no forced entry. Angela was shot in the head as she slept (≈6–12 inches); Latoya was shot through neck/chest from >24 inches while in bed; Lakeisha – found in a separate bedroom – was shot at close range (≈6–12 inches) with defensive abrasions consistent with an attempt to protect herself. A large-caliber revolver was inferred; phones were ripped from their bases and thrown, with Black’s fingerprints the only ones recovered. The jury’s aggravators included the child-victim factor and that Lakeisha’s killing was to avoid arrest/prosecution – consistent with eliminating a witness.

Timeline of the Byron Lewis Black Case →

  • Dec. 1986: Black shoots Angela’s estranged husband; later on work-release for that offense.
  • Mar. 28, 1988: Angela (29), Latoya (9) shot in master bedroom; Lakeisha (6) shot in second bedroom; all three die.
  • 1988–89: Indicted/tried in Davidson County.
  • Mar. 8–10, 1989: Jury convicts; death for Lakeisha; life sentences for Angela & Latoya.
  • 1991: TN Supreme Court affirms convictions; death sentence stands.
  • 2010s–2020s: Habeas & clemency litigated; new single-drug protocol adopted statewide late 2024.
  • Jul. 31, 2025: TN Supreme Court clears execution to proceed notwithstanding implanted ICD.
  • Aug. 5, 2025: Execution carried out; witnesses report Black complained of severe pain.

→ Quick Answers

  • Where/when? Nashville, TN – Mar. 28, 1988.
  • Victims? Angela Clay (29), Latoya (9), Lakeisha (6).
  • Motive/theme? Domestic jealousy/control; prior violence against the family.
  • Forensic anchors? Close-range gunshot evidence; scene reconstruction consistent with verdict.
  • Outcome? Death + two life terms; executed Aug. 5, 2025.

Case Summary | Byron Lewis Black

On March 28, 1988, while out on weekend work-release from a prior felony, Byron Lewis Black entered Angela Clay’s Nashville apartment and fatally shot Angela (29) and her daughters Latoya (9) and Lakeisha (6); the locked-door scene and close-range ballistics anchored the State’s case.
In 1989 a Davidson County jury convicted him of three counts of first-degree murder, imposing death for Lakeisha’s killing and two life sentences for Angela and Latoya.
After decades of state and federal litigation – including Sixth Circuit rulings (2011, 2017) and a 2023 TCCA decision—Tennessee carried out his execution by lethal injection on August 5, 2025, following a high-profile dispute over deactivating his implanted defibrillator.

🕊️Victims of Byron Lewis Black Victims

  • Angela Clay, 29 – Mother of Latoya and Lakeisha. Found in the master bedroom, under the covers, shot once in the top of the head at close range (approx. 6–12 inches); she was rendered unconscious immediately and died within minutes. No signs of forced entry; the apartment door was locked when police arrived that night after her family could not reach her. Investigators later recovered the kitchen phone receiver in the master bedroom and another phone in the hallway – bearing Byron Black’s fingerprints.

The Children

  • Latoya Clay, 9 – Discovered partially on and partially off the master bed, wedged between the mattress and a chest of drawers. She was shot once through the neck and chest from more than 24 inches away; medical testimony indicated she likely died within three to ten minutes. Blood on the pillow and a bullet path consistent with being shot while lying down placed the attack as she lay in bed.
  • Lakeisha (“Lakesha”) Clay, 6 – Found facedown on the floor beside her bed in a separate bedroom. She suffered two gunshot wounds (chest and pelvic area) fired at close range (approx. 6–12 inches) and died within five to thirty minutes. Abrasions on her arm and bloody fingermarks along the bed rail indicated movement and defensive effort after an initial shot while in bed. The separation of rooms and sequence evidence supported that she was attacked after her mother and sister.

→ FAQs

Was Black on work release when the murders happened?

Yes. He was on a weekend furlough from the Davidson County Metropolitan Workhouse for a prior malicious-shooting conviction. He was released Friday, March 25, 1988, and returned at ~5:15 p.m. Monday, March 28 – after the killings but before the bodies were discovered that night.

Why did the jury impose death for only one count?

He received life for Angela and Latoya and death for Lakeisha (6). The court upheld death based on aggravators – most notably that Lakeisha’s killing was to avoid arrest/prosecution (witness elimination) and other factors; the opinion discusses the aggravators in detail.

What evidence tied him to the crime?

No forced entry; the door was locked. Neighbors heard four gunshots around 1:00–1:30 a.m. Inside, close-range wounds (6–12 inches for Angela and Lakeisha; >24 inches for Latoya). Telephones ripped and tossed bore Black’s fingerprints (and no one else’s). The State also presented prior threats/door-kicking, his inconsistent statements about that night and the gun used to shoot Bennie Clay in 1986.

What happened at his 2025 execution?

A legal fight centered on whether Tennessee had to deactivate his implanted defibrillator (ICD). A judge initially ordered deactivation; the Tennessee Supreme Court later allowed the execution to proceed without requiring it. On Aug. 5, 2025, Black was executed by lethal injection; multiple witnesses reported he said “It’s hurting so bad” and showed signs of pain.

Byron Lewis Black | Triple Murder

The Story

The Separation and the First Shot

Before the murders, Angela Clay had left her husband, Bennie, and was seeing Byron Lewis Black. The triangle didn’t simmer quietly. In December 1986, Black shot Bennie in the shoulder—a felony that landed Black a two-year sentence with work-release privileges. The violence didn’t vanish; it just moved to the margins of a schedule.

A Weekend Furlough

On March 28, 1988, Black was out on his work-release window. Sometime in the pre-dawn hours, neighbors on Wade Avenue heard a handful of spaced gunshots. By nightfall, when Angela’s family couldn’t reach her, they asked police to check the apartment.

A Locked Door, a Dark Apartment

Officers arrived around 9:30 p.m. The door was locked and there were no signs of forced entry. A screen was pried from a bedroom window so an officer could see inside. The lights were off. A flashlight sweep across a child’s room caught the unmistakable shape of a small body on the floor and a spreading pool of blood.

The Master Bedroom

In the main bedroom, Angela (29) lay under the covers, a single shot to the top of her head – close range, on the order of inches – suggesting she was shot while asleep and likely died within minutes. Nearby, Latoya (9) was found partly on and partly off the bed, wedged between the mattress and a dresser. Blood on the pillow and a hole through bedding aligned with a shot from greater than two feet away, consistent with being struck while lying down; medical testimony placed death minutes later, not instant.

The Second Bedroom

In a separate room, Lakeisha (6) lay facedown beside her bed. She had two gunshot wounds – chest and pelvic region – fired at close range. Grazing injuries on her arm and bloody fingermarks along the bed rail suggested she was shot in bed, tried to move, and collapsed to the floor. Her fatal wound to the chest led to rapid blood loss; the estimated survival window was measured in minutes.

What the Room Told Investigators

No shell casings were recovered – pointing to a large-caliber revolver rather than a semi-automatic pistol. Two telephones had been torn from service: the kitchen receiver ended up in the master bedroom, and another phone lay in the hallway between the rooms. Latent prints lifted from the dislodged phones belonged to Byron Black; no other prints were usable. Projectiles and fragments were collected from the bedding, wall, and mattress in places that matched the wounds and the sequence investigators reconstructed.

The Suspect and the Gun History

In the days that followed, detectives focused on Black. Biological evidence was scarce, but the State leaned on scene reconstruction, the locked-door circumstance, prior threats and violence, the work-release timing, the relocated phones bearing his fingerprints, and comparative firearms analysis referencing Black’s earlier 1986 shooting of Bennie. The picture, to prosecutors, was a domestic ambush carried out at close range.

From Charge to Trial

Black was arrested in April 1988 and indicted on three counts of first-degree murder, with the State announcing it would seek death. He challenged competency, pursued an alibi, and at one point claimed he had found the victims’ bodies. Jury selection began in February 1989; the proof centered on the locked apartment, the ballistic/pathology evidence, the prior shooting, and the ripped telephones with his prints.

Verdict and Sentencing

On March 8, 1989, the jury found Black guilty of all three murders. Two days later, the penalty phase split: for Lakeisha’s murder, jurors unanimously returned death; for Angela and Latoya, the court imposed consecutive life sentences when jurors did not reach death on those counts. Additional terms followed for burglary and firearms offenses. An execution date was set for November 20, 1989, then stayed for appeals.

Aftermath and Arc of the Case

Appellate courts later affirmed the convictions and death sentence. Decades on, amid Tennessee’s protocol changes and late litigation, Black’s case moved from docket to death chamber. On August 5, 2025, the State carried out the sentence by lethal injection—closing, in law if not in memory, the story that began in a locked, darkened apartment on Wade Avenue.

Byron Lewis Black | Triple Murder In Nashville

JOIN US

Fireside Crime Stories

If the written word keeps you leaning forward into the shadows, then you’ll love settling back by the fire with us. On our YouTube channel, these same haunting stories are told in a softer voice – woven with stormlight, fire crackle, and quiet piano. Perfect for late-night listening, or for those who want to drift into slumber carried by true crime whispers instead of headlines. Step into the firelight, and join us there.

FIRESIDE CRIME STORIES

Legal Status | Paper Trail | Byron Lewis Black

📚 Additional Resources

📚 Further Reading / Watching

This site contains affiliate links. We may, at no cost to you, receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Thank you for your support.

👉 This page is part of the WickedWe True Crime Archive – a resource for researchers, students, and true crime enthusiasts seeking verified facts, case records, and deeper historical context. [Disclaimer→ WickedWe.com is an educational/entertainment column only. No graphic imagery. Victim-respect policy. Nothing herein is legal advice.]

Beyond the Gavel

Roll Card | Byron Lewis Black (TN)

Docket Map | Proceedings (Condensed)

Stay / Warrant / Window | Byron Lewis Black

Case File Extras | What the Record Shows

Source Pack (primary docs)

Our Shop

Related Posts